Overall rating: 2.4754097 / 5 from 183 reviews.
The All-Day Eyeliner Pencil offers a convenient sharpener and a smooth glide, though opinions on its effectiveness and color vary. Customers appreciate the brand's non-irritating properties, but some find the formula breaks easily. The black raisin color is popular for everyday use.
Review topics: ["color","amount","skin","issues","look","eyes","shade","price","liner","lines","use","works","found","eyeliner","pencil","almay","brand","pearl","sharpener","topaz","version","reaction","glides","smudging","mascara","makeup","customers","stick","users","bring"].
"I have been using this black eyeliner for many years now. It goes on like butter and lasts all day. I have very sensitive eyes that get allergic reactions easily, but this eyeliner doesn’t irritate my eyes at all hence why this is the only eyeliner I use!"
"I had found an “intense I-color black pearl” manufactured in 2009 in my mother’s make up box and I loved it, but recently it completely broke so we went to find a new one; the intense I-color was out so we tried this one and… it was horrible! It doesn’t go on nicely or smoothly on my waterline at all like the I-color, it smudged like crazy, doesn’t even apply nicely as a fake tattoo type of pencil and it wouldn’t come off with a make up wipe by less m applied serious force. Which—by the way—isn’t ideal when the product is on your FRIGGEN EYES!!! I got so many compliments with the intense I-color, it only lasted so long because it was rarely used and I had found it about a month ago. But this all day one? Complete and utter garbage 😭😭 maybe it’s intended for wings instead of the emo type of look I do daily, but it was the only make up I’d put on daily and I genuinely was starting to freak out when I realized this wasn’t working at all, nor was it even good."
"I loved Almay's Intense-I color eyeliner. When I bought the eye pencil, I thought the packaging had changed. The eye pencil is horrible. I bought four of them on sale, and wish I had realized they weren't the Intense-i color eyeliner. They are a complete waste of money."
"I purchased this a month ago--the topaz bronze is no longer bronze, but a dark brown. It odes not apply nicely for eyebrows. The previous formula was excellent. I will not purchase this again."
"I have spent countless money on eyeliners for 30 years. I've bought super expensive from Ulta all the way down to the cheapest stick you have to sharpen and this eyeliner literally stayed ALL day, didn't dissappear anf didn't smear. This is my forever choice now."
"I don’t know what is going on with this company but the quality has gone downhill quick. The intense I-color in purple amethyst was amazing. Great color. Smooth glide. Stayed in place and HYPOALLERGENIC. The “newer” black amethyst flakes, goes on like your using a kids crayon and makes the eyes itch. I’m so disappointed. They can’t possibly be struggling to find customers who actually NEED and WANT products to that are hypoallergenic. If the company is struggling, it’s because they’re cheaping out on ingredients and driving customers away."
"I have used Almay Eyeliner Pencils for many years! Now that I am considered a senior citizen, I still like to use eyeliner. This is my favorite eyeliner pencil! It lasts all day without smudging; it's self-sharpening, and one eyeliner pencil lasts and lasts! I recommend these Almay Eyeliner Pencils to everyone who is looking for a great eyeliner at a fair price!"
"The best eyeliner for all day wear! Wish Target, Walmart, and Longs still sold it in their stores. I can’t find it anywhere."
"I luv how this product goes on my water line, however, the point breaks off after each use. Seems like in between uses the point gets hard & breaks off T the next use. Then goes on we'll w/new point. Then repeats w/getting hard and breaking off. How long will this product last at that rate of waste?? I do luv the color I believe it was brown raisin. Once this pencil is used (and it shouldn't take long) I will not be purchasing again."
"Why would you make a product that can't be sharpened or advanced? When I purchased thought I would be able to use the entire pencil. Wrong! Not happy"
