Brown eyeliner
"Positives: hypoallergenic, nice brown color Negatives: parabens and brush doesn't last"
Overall rating: 3.9950738 / 5 from 406 reviews.
This hypoallergenic liquid eyeliner is praised for its bold and precise look, suitable for sensitive eyes. Customers appreciate its long-lasting color that stays on all day without smudging. However, opinions on the brush and applicator are mixed, with some finding it difficult to create straight lines and uncomfortable to use. The formula has received mixed reviews, and the price is considered great and affordable.
Review topics: ["eyes","coverage","eyeliner","tip"].
"Positives: hypoallergenic, nice brown color Negatives: parabens and brush doesn't last"
"First time I used it my eyes immediately got itchy. I washed it off within 5 minutes, but the next day one eye was swollen. Not sure what I reacted to if it is hypoallergenic…"
"Best eyeliner to outline eyes. Easy to wash off and correct if I get too much on to perfect how much I want to use. Trust that it’s also hypo allergenic. I’ve used this eyeliner for 20+years"
"Not enough color pigment. Seems watered down even after all the shaking i did. Bought 2 of them from different locations and both were the same"
"I bought this kind at Walmart a week ago, and i love it. It has good coverage, its very strong black, well defined, the pen tip was pretty sharp so super easy to do my wings, DEFINITELY recommend, hope its visible in this pic. Love it"
"Best eyeliner for sensitive eyes! Been using for a few years now!"
"I used to love this product, but they must have changed the formula because now I can’t keep it on my eye. It ends up smudging and beneath my eye every day. This is going straight in the trash. Very disappointing."
"I got this yesterday at Walmart because they didn’t have elf, and I assumed it would be good because it was expensive, but it was just a waste of my money. The brush is dull, not sharp at all, and the eyeliner itself has horrible coverage, looks like it was done with a crayola marker. If I could leave zero stars I would."
"I loved the Brown Topaz of the previous version. This new Brown is way too dark. Please bring back the previous version, or add a lighter, shimmery brown option. Since Brown Topaz got discontinued, I've been using other brands that have a shade similar to Brown Topaz, but I would rather use Almay."
"Agree with other reviews regarding the applicator. It is not the same as it used to be. Noticed the change during covid, 2020. The applicator frays and makes it nearly impossible to use. The tip usually becomes more flexible with use but the fraying it horrible. I like this because it comes in brown and the eyeliner comes off easily when applying if you make a mistake. Please fix this applicator!!!!"