Review topics: [size, fragrance, irritation, fit, quality, value, skin, issues, results, feeling, packaging, scent, package, design, texture, works, bottle, ingredients, look, price, eyes, residue, formula, pads, face, container, oil, mascara, consistency, sensation].
Reviews
I can't find my old makeup pad removers :(
"I have been to every store where I bought my Alma pads for many years. Everyone has said they don't carry them now. . After much time spent traveling from store to store, and walking up and down isles hoping the sales person was mistaken, I went online to Amazon and the product looks different. The white containers are no more. I went on this website to see if I could order the original product and I'm seeing one negative review after another about the change in formula, and I see that the packaging is now 50% post consumer. I don't want that for my beauty products. Too many chemicals going into recycling plastics in my opinion. And it looks like the recipe is also changed. Why Almay did you do this terrible thing??"
— Dee R. (5/5)
A good combination of products!
"The mascara added nice length and definition without feeling heavy, and the makeup remover pads easily took it off at the end of the day. A great combo that's gentle on my sensitive eyes!"
— ElenaM (4/5)
They do not work at all
"I am a long time user of the oil free Mascara remover pads. I even turned my granddaughter's on to their effectiveness. The new formula does not work at all it feels like water and does not remove any mascara. I am so disappointed and will be seeking out another brand that does the"
— JOANN H. (1/5)
Effective and Gentle
"These work pretty well. They removed the mascara with little effort and left my lashes in tact. They are pretty oily and will make your eyes foggy if you get any of the oil in your eye. You get plenty of little remover pads in a single jar, and I only use one on each eye. They have been handy and convenient to have around on the lazy days where I need to take of WATERPROOF mascara. I like them."
— JennaM (4/5)
Don’t like it
"To be honest I don’t like it. My eyes are irritated by this product. I don’t like the performance, drying, dissolving, staining, but I do like the packaging."
— KaryL (1/5)
awful product 0/10
"didnt like. really harsh kn the skin made removal unbearable, lots of grease and didn’t even get all the product off. the amount is good at least 100 sheets of pure sandpaper. dont buy it its awful"
— SophyG (1/5)
Quick and easy pads for even stubborn mascara!
"I’ve been using these eye makeup remover pads and they work really well! They easily remove waterproof mascara and eye makeup without a lot of rubbing. I like that they’re gentle, and hypoallergenic, and safe for sensitive eyes. The biodegradable pads are also a nice bonus since they’re better for the environment. Definitely a quick and convenient way to remove makeup at the end of the day!"
— KristinaK (5/5)
Almay Biodegradable longwear and waterproof eye m
"I’ve been loving these makeup removing pads! They remove even stubborn waterproof mascara without harsh rubbing, which is a huge plus for my sensitive eyes! The pads feel soft, not overly oily, and they don’t leave a heavy residue behind. I also really appreciate that they are biodegradable- it makes my nightly routine feel a little more eco conscious. Super convenient, gentle and effective. Definitely a repurchase for me!"
— EkaterinaM (5/5)
Why change it for the worse?
"I have used this product for more than a decade; always great. Most recent purchase has new labeling and a terribly degraded product. Pads are virtually dry and do not remove mascara, liner, etc. without a great deal of abuse to eye area. Leaves a lot behind. Very disappointing!"
— Lrizzo (1/5)
What happened?
"Have used Almay in past, no problems, new pads recently purchased are like wet cardboard chips. Think I will just toss and source a new eye makeup remover pad."
— Kerry S. (1/5)
